Thoughts from a Therapist

Psychology, Relationships, Meaning, and the Conditions that make Change

When Should We Set a Boundary and When Should We Stay Open?

When we think about two people, a marriage, two parents, two towns, it helps to picture two rooms sharing a wall with a window in it. No window is disengagement. No wall is enmeshment. How open the window can be depends on reciprocity, and “I don’t feel safe” is often a report that the reciprocity…

When we think about a system of two people, a marriage, two parents, two towns, it is useful to use a metaphor: two rooms that share a wall, with a window in the wall. The rooms are the two people, the wall is what keeps them separate, and the window is the influence they allow to pass between them.

If there is no window, that is disengagement, two people who no longer influence or help each other. If there is no wall, that is enmeshment, two people fused into one with no second self left. The window is the healthy middle: two differentiated people who have influence over each other. How open it can be depends on reciprocity, how equal the help is that moves between the two rooms, which again are two people.

The two rooms come from the post on thinking systemically, where a family was a house and each person was a room. The third post, How Do We Deconstruct a Problem Systemically?, runs three problems through the variables that maintain them.

How open the window can be depends on how much reciprocity the two people have grown.

The Theory in Short

The wall

Differentiation

Each person is a room and the relationship is the wall between them. A healthy relationship keeps the wall and decides how much of it is window.

The window

Reciprocity and co-influence

The influence two people let pass between them. It can stay open to the degree that both are giving and receiving, and both are willing to be changed by the other.

Codependence

One person doing all the heating

When one person spends everything to keep the other afloat, the relationship looks stable from the outside and is consuming one of the two people to produce the stability.

“I don’t feel safe”

Two meanings

Sometimes an accurate report of danger. Often a report that the window is not working: with it open I cannot hold my values, reach my goals, or protect my resources. The first calls for protection. The second calls for a boundary.

A Fair Question

Are you saying that if one person is too hot, the other person should do everything they can to change that person’s temperature, and that boundaries are unnecessary?

No. Depending on the relative and contextual variables, we decide how much openness or closedness we will have with another person: how much value the two of us share, how much each has already spent trying to hold the other steady, whether what comes through the window changes both of us or only drains one of us, and whether leaving is possible at all. Sometimes the degree is a choice we get to make and sometimes it is not. A child does not choose the house. For now, the cases where we can choose.

Two Rooms That Want to Stay Rooms

In the first post, the father was an 85-degree room who answered a request to cool down by going to 100, and the cooler room next to him boarded up the window. That boarding up is the move this post is about, taken slowly.

Take a husband and a wife and seal the rest of the house off. Both of them want to remain themselves. In terms of healthy identity and differentiation, we do not remove the wall between them, because a marriage with no wall is one person wearing two names. We also do not seal the wall, because a marriage with no window is two people who have stopped influencing or helping each other. The question is the window.

Two terms do the work here. Reciprocity is both people participating in what the shared window requires: each one giving help and receiving it, each one adjusting for the other. Co-influence is the result: what happens in my life changes yours, and what happens in yours changes mine, in both directions and not only one.

I would argue that the degree depends on the ability of the two people to grow enough similarity between them. If both of them are doing well, both rooms at 75, a window helps: each one steadies the other, and the exchange costs neither of them anything. Now suppose one of them is burning everything they have, a fireplace running constantly, and the other has a window open to the outside, so that whatever help reaches them leaves as fast as it arrives. The pair might still achieve some kind of balance at the shared window, and the balance is being produced by one person burning all of their fuel to hold up a partner who is not holding their own. That is a codependent relationship.

A balance produced by one person doing all the heating is codependence.

From the outside the marriage reads fine. Here is the arrangement drawn out.

What We Mean When We Say Safe

A lot of people are using the word safety right now. Sometimes it is true. Sometimes it is a misuse of the word, and what the person means is that the two of them do not have enough reciprocity, enough shared value system, to make leaving the window open a good decision. The modern habit, as always, is to overuse and exaggerate the term.

I don’t feel safe opening the window.

What we often mean is closer to this. I don’t think the window is effective. I don’t think I can maintain the integrity of my own value system with it open. I don’t think I can reach my goals and support my resources while your heat is coming through. Those are real reports about effectiveness and shared values. When we call them safety, we borrow the authority of danger for a problem of reciprocity, and the other person hears that they are dangerous when what is true is that the two of them have not grown enough in common.

When the window is not effective, there are three moves, and the less reciprocity there is between the two people, the larger the move has to be.

Add insulation

The smallest boundary

Less of the other person’s influence gets through. The window stays.

Shut the window

The exchange ends

We stop influencing each other and stay in the same house. The wall is still shared.

Different houses

Full disconnection

In a marriage, separation. The two people stop sharing a wall at all.

Why a Marriage Keeps the Window Open Anyway

In an effective marriage, the goal, if the two people want to stay together, is to keep the window open to a degree: enough wall to support each person’s identity, enough window to allow reciprocal influence and then assistance. Neither person is the problem for needing something from the other. People are not problems, and a marriage in which one person has been named the problem has not yet found a way to accommodate what that person needs.

From a systemic perspective we do help each other. In a forest, the soil, the mycelium, the decomposition, and the water are in union with one another. The soil is not compromising with the mycelium and wishing there were no mycelium. Each one’s function is part of what makes the other’s function possible. A marriage with the window open to the right degree works the same way: the influence coming through is what makes each person’s identity more possible.

The Seven Tensions at the Window

The two rooms do not have to be two spouses. Two parents, two towns, two political parties face the same question of how much window the wall can hold. Dialectic and Deconstruction Solutions tests every proposed solution against seven recurring tensions (more on my model for civic solutions at SolveSomething.com), each one a pair of goods that pull against each other. The degree to which the two poles can feed each other instead of one trying to win is the degree to which the window can stay open.

The country is a current example of the window shut, with the two rooms being the two parties. Each believes it needs to keep the window closed, and both use contemptuous language toward the other to justify it. I am not going into who is more valid. Systemically, the question is what humility would have to happen for the window to open: where could either side say, we went too far toward our pole on this. Regulation is my favorite example because the dialectic is so plain. We need regulation for safety and the collective good, we need deregulation to remove unnecessary inefficiencies, and we need people willing to say out loud when a regulation has stopped protecting anything. If each side takes one of those needs and refuses the other, the window closes.

Freedom and safety: sharing a road

The two rooms are two drivers, and the window is the road. Either I am not on the road with you, or we have reciprocity about how we use it.

Full freedom means we drive as fast and however we want, and the road becomes a race track with the rest of us on it. Full safety means nobody drives. An AI runs every car, calibrating my speed and everyone’s so that everyone arrives with the least risk and the least waste, and the collective has overruled the individual, which is how these tensions nest inside each other.

A road we can share exists only because the two drivers influence each other: freedom accepts a limit, and safety accepts a risk.

Individual and collective: the fish in the lake

The two rooms are one fisherman and his village. I come up with a system that traps all the fish in a lake. Now I have unlimited fish, and I sell them to my village at a monopolized price. That is the failure mode of capitalism in one picture: my brilliant design, which could have served the community I live in, serves only me.

The opposite pole is that the system is taken over by a centralized authority and everyone receives the same fish in the same portion. The village eats, and the world goes bland. A chef in that village cannot ask which part of the fish she would like for her own creative offering, because none of that is available to her.

The window stays open when the fisherman keeps his design and his profit and the village keeps its ability to eat: he sells at a price the village can pay, and the village lets him be the one who got rich from the lake.

Efficiency and humanity: trash in the river

The two rooms are upstream and downstream. The most efficient way for the wealthy part of town, the part by the river, to get rid of its trash is to throw it in the river. Humanity takes into account that my efficiency is destroying the potable water of the people below me.

The people downstream cannot shut this window. The river opens in one direction, and the only boundary available to them is the one the people upstream agree to. I often use this example for freedom and safety too, my freedom to dump against your safety downstream, which is the nature of the tensions: the same example lives inside more than one of them.

The window stays open when upstream keeps its efficiency and downstream keeps its water: the trash goes somewhere that costs the people by the river a little more and costs the people below them nothing.

Transparency and privacy: what reaches the children

The two rooms are adults who want an open internet and parents of young children. Full transparency means anything can be published with no liability for restricting access, and your children can reach misinformation, algorithms built to addict them, pornography, and horror movies they are not developmentally ready for.

The privacy pole, taken all the way, means adults do not get to choose the content they enjoy, because all of it is censored on someone’s behalf. I hate horror movies. I do not want to see an ad for one. Too far toward privacy, and my dislike has become everyone’s prohibition.

The window stays open when adults keep their choice and children keep their protection: the content stays available, and access to it is gated by age rather than removed for everyone.

Justice and mercy: the founders and the fundamentalists

Religious fundamentalism is where this tension becomes ironic. Nearly all of the founders of those religions were advocates of mercy, and their present-day fundamentalist representation is justice alone: here is the rule, you broke it, you are going to hell, and we are going to kill you with a rock. Mercy is the humility of accepting the realities of the human condition.

The same tension closes a window between two parents. If I am permissive of everything, and my child can do drugs, talk back to anyone, and skip every responsibility, while the other parent is so strict that the child has no room for experimentation or ordinary development, the window between us has to close. Neither pole can receive influence from the other.

The window stays open when the rule stays and the human condition is admitted. Between two parents, the strict one keeps the line, the permissive one keeps the room to experiment, and the child gets both a line and a way back across it.

Innovation and tradition: how we offer mental health

The two rooms are a clinician who wants to change the field and a system that wants to keep it. If I want to revolutionize how we offer mental health care, and you want the current bureaucratic system with third-party payers and a non-systemic diagnostic orientation, we are going to have to keep the window closed.

Tradition carries what the system still needs to remember, innovation corrects what tradition could not see, and neither of us gets the benefit of the other’s pole while the window is shut.

The window stays open when the reformer keeps what the old system learned, the parts that still protect clients and clinicians, and the system lets the parts that stopped serving anyone be rebuilt.

Urgency and sustainability: two towns and the water

The two rooms are two towns with a contaminant in the water they could treat together. One takes the long view: effective filtration will take high levels of infrastructure and money. The other wants to pour in everything, bromide, chlorine, iodine, whatever kills it, and kill it now.

The urgent solution kills the disease and makes the water unpotable unless a household has a ten-thousand-dollar filtration system of its own, so it also defeated the humanity of the town. The sustainable solution cannot solve the problem tomorrow; the towns will be distributing bottled water for a while. In the end it is the one that takes everyone in the system into consideration. If the two towns cannot come to co-influence, the window between them stays shut. It stays open when they do both: the urgent dose now, with the bottled water and the in-home filters paid for by both towns together, while the lasting filtration gets built.

Every example carries more than one tension

None of the seven holds still inside its own tension, which is why a window between two people, or two towns, or two parties, is never a single negotiation. Several tensions are open at once, and the two sides can agree on one and be shut on another.

ExampleThe two roomsFiled underAlso in play
Sharing a roadThe two roomsTwo driversFiled underFreedom and safetyAlso in playEfficiency and humanity, individual and collective
The fish in the lakeThe two roomsA fisherman and his villageFiled underIndividual and collectiveAlso in playEfficiency and humanity, justice and mercy
Trash in the riverThe two roomsUpstream and downstreamFiled underEfficiency and humanityAlso in playFreedom and safety, individual and collective
What reaches the childrenThe two roomsOpen-internet adults and parentsFiled underTransparency and privacyAlso in playFreedom and safety, justice and mercy
Two parents, permissive and strictThe two roomsTwo parentsFiled underJustice and mercyAlso in playFreedom and safety, innovation and tradition
How we offer mental healthThe two roomsA reformer and the systemFiled underInnovation and traditionAlso in playEfficiency and humanity, urgency and sustainability
Two towns and the waterThe two roomsTwo townsFiled underUrgency and sustainabilityAlso in playEfficiency and humanity, individual and collective
The same examples, read across tensions

What Keeps a Window Open

Two people, or two groups, can share a window to the degree that each is willing to receive influence from the other and each has enough identity left to be worth influencing. Where reciprocity has been grown, the boundary can be small. Where it has not, the boundary has to be larger, and calling that a safety problem hides the actual work, which is growing enough shared value for the window to open again.

Whether the two rooms are a marriage, two parents, two towns, or two parties, the wall is staying. What remains open between them is a measure of how much they have agreed to be changed by each other, and that measure was grown, and it can be grown further or lost, by the same two people, under the same roof.

© 2026 William Hambleton Bishop. Quote with attribution and a link to this post.